Anthony Setaro

Anthony Setaro is a Monmouth County real estate professional with a decade of experience, known for his grounded approach and deep connection to the communities he serves. Before entering real estate, he was Vice President of Sounds To Go DJ’s, working as an event host and DJ. His path into real estate was shaped by purpose—after volunteering in the aftermath of Superstorm Sandy, he co-founded the non-profit RebuildRecover, coordinating with borough officials, engineers, and FEMA to demolish over 400 homes and help displaced families rebuild their lives. He later produced the award-winning film After Sandy, documenting the experience and impact on local residents.

Anthony specializes in historic homes, luxury properties, listings, and working with clients in the entertainment industry. Known for being down to earth, straightforward, and highly knowledgeable, he brings a no-nonsense approach while remaining understanding and compassionate throughout the process. His focus is on strategy, education, and clear communication—helping clients make confident decisions whether buying or selling in today’s market. He is a New Jersey Circle of Excellence Award winner and a member of Align, a Mega Icon Team at eXp Realty.

Outside of real estate, Anthony is deeply connected to local history, Italian heritage and culture, and the arts. His passion for storytelling extends into film, theatre, and acting, and he continues to explore and preserve the rich history of Monmouth County through his work and personal pursuits.